en-USfa-IR

papers

As noted elsewhere, TILO's members are not just practice-oriented attorneys. Rather, they have made an extensive contribution to the development of legal scholarship. They have published both nationally and internationally in top ranked journals including but not limited to Florida Journal of International Law, Nordic Journal of Commercial Law, Tehran Univ. Law Journal, etc. in the following pages you may have an access to examples of TILO's member's scholarship.

Judgment for Specific Performance against Obligor and its Implementation by Third Party in Iranian and French Law

Ebrahim Shoarian Sattari 
Sevda Bahojb Azim

DOI: 10.22059/JCL.2020.298369.633977

Abstract
In contractual relationships, accurate and timely implementation of obligations is of particular importance. But sometimes the obligor commits a breach of contract and, in spite of the issuance of the court judgment for specific performance, he still refuses to carry out obligation. Subject to the provisions of Articles 222, 238 of the Civil Code and Article 47 of the Code of the Execution of Civil Judgments, where the obligation is enforceable by a person other than the obligor, the third party may perform the obligation or even the obligee himself fulfill the obligation and claim for the cost of such performance. Also in Article 1222 of the French New Civil Code, which replaced the former Article 1144, such a performance has been recognized. A comparative study of the issue can provide an accurate response to some questions which has been raised in the issue. Third - party involvement in the implementation of obligation is only conceivable in the obligations to do and not to do which has no personal aspect. A comparative study of French law, that inspired the drafters of Iranian Civil Code, shows that such performance by a third party is a kind of specific performance and the discharging of original obligor is its main effect which consequently all of the guarantees will be extinguished, meanwhile the obligor will be condemned to pay expenses of performance.

 

Name
Last Name
E-Mail

Save Information


 
 
 
Register Forgot Password ?